In the metal roof vs shingles decision for a Minnesota home, metal generally wins on lifespan, snow shedding and wind testing, while asphalt shingles win on upfront cost, simple repairs and snow that stays put instead of sliding off. Neither one prevents ice dams by itself; that depends on the attic underneath.
This guide compares how each roof actually behaves through a Twin Cities year: heavy snow, freeze-thaw cycles, ice dams, spring and summer hail, and strong winds. Cost comes up only briefly at the end, because the right answer for most homeowners depends more on the house and how long you plan to stay than on the sticker price.
In this article
- Metal Roof vs Shingles at a Glance
- How Each Roof Handles Minnesota Snow
- Ice Dams: Neither Material Is Immune
- Hail Resistance and Insurance
- Wind Ratings Compared
- Cold Weather and Installation Season
- Lifespan, Maintenance and Repairs
- Is a Metal Roof Louder in Rain or Hail?
- Cost and Resale Value
- Which Roof Fits Your Minneapolis Home?
- Frequently Asked Questions
Metal Roof vs Shingles at a Glance
The table below sums up the main differences. The sections that follow explain the “why” behind each row, and where the details depend on the specific product and installation.
| Factor | Metal roofing | Asphalt shingles |
|---|---|---|
| Estimated life expectancy* | 40 to 80 years | About 20 years (3-tab) to 30 years (architectural) |
| Snow behavior | Slick surface sheds snow, sometimes suddenly; snow guards often needed | Rough surface holds snow until it melts or is raked |
| Ice dams | Can still form at eaves and gutters | Can still form; water backs up under shingles |
| Hail | Usually dents rather than breaks; many products impact-rated | Bruising, cracking and granule loss; impact-rated (Class 4) shingles available |
| Wind testing | Uplift tests such as UL 580, UL 1897 and ASTM E1592 | ASTM D3161 Class D (90 mph) or Class F (110 mph) |
| Noise | Similar to other roofs over a solid deck with underlayment and insulation | Quiet |
| Repairs | Panels must match profile and color; more specialized | Individual shingles are easy to replace |
| National average replacement cost (2025)** | About $51,900 | About $31,900 |
| Share of cost recouped at resale (2025)** | About 50% | About 68% |
*Estimates from InterNACHI’s life expectancy chart, which the organization describes as guidelines rather than promises. **Remodeling’s Cost vs Value 2025 national averages for a roughly 3,000-square-foot tear-off and replacement; Minneapolis prices vary by project.
How Each Roof Handles Minnesota Snow
Snow is where the two materials behave most differently. Asphalt shingles have a gritty, granule-covered surface that grips snow, so it tends to stay on the roof until it melts or someone pulls it off with a roof rake from the ground. Metal is smooth, and that changes everything about how snow leaves the roof.
Why snow slides off metal roofs
As snow on a roof melts and refreezes, it forms layers that can shear apart. On metal, the low friction of the panel surface lets that break happen right at the roof, so the whole snowpack can slide at once. A technical bulletin from metal panel maker Metl-Span notes the risk grows with roof pitch, and that uncontrolled sliding can damage gutters, lower roofs and people or property below.
The Metal Roofing Alliance warns that a rooftop “avalanche” can release thousands of pounds of snow in a split second. That is a real hazard above entry doors, walkways, driveways, decks, and anything mounted below the eave.
The upside of shedding snow
Shedding is not all bad. A roof that clears itself carries less snow weight for less time, and you are less likely to need snow removal after a big storm. Minnesota’s building rules set a ground snow load of 50 pounds per square foot for Hennepin County and the other counties not on the northern list, and roofs are designed with that kind of load in mind. A shingle roof keeps more of that weight up top through the winter.
Snow guards: what they do and where they go
Snow guards (also called snow retention systems) are metal brackets or bars fastened to the roof that hold snow in place so it melts off gradually instead of dumping all at once. On a metal roof in the Twin Cities, they are worth planning from the start rather than adding after a close call.
- Cover the whole eave, not just the door. The Metal Roofing Alliance advises against putting guards only above doorways, because partial coverage makes shedding less predictable.
- Size them to the roof. Layout should be based on local ground snow load, panel profile, slope and the length of the roof run, and prescribed by the guard manufacturer or an experienced installer.
- Use durable, mechanically fastened parts. Guards should be noncorrosive metal meant to last as long as the roof. Glue-on plastic products that aren’t mechanically attached are a weak point.
- Match the attachment to the panel. Standing-seam roofs typically use clamps that grip the seam, while exposed-fastener panels use brackets screwed through the panel. Either way, follow the roofing and guard manufacturers’ instructions.
The same alliance notes that there are no codes or standards governing snow guard installation, which is why the design should come from the manufacturer’s engineering rather than guesswork.
Gutters on metal roofs
Sliding snow and ice can shear gutters right off the fascia. Snow guards help, and in heavy-snow areas some metal roofing suppliers recommend oversized gutters and downspouts. Some designers skip gutters on certain eaves entirely. Talk through drainage, guards and gutters together before the roof goes on.
Safety note: Never climb onto any roof to clear snow, and metal roofs are especially slippery. Use a roof rake from the ground, stay well away from power lines (aluminum rakes conduct electricity), and hire a professional for anything you can’t reach safely.
Ice Dams: Neither Material Is Immune
A common belief is that metal roofs don’t get ice dams. They can. The University of Minnesota Extension explains that ice dams need three things: snow on the roof, an upper roof surface above 32°F, and a lower roof edge below 32°F. Warm air leaking from the house into the attic is usually what heats the upper roof, and that has nothing to do with the roofing material.
Ice dams on metal
Because snow slides more readily off metal, there is often less snow left to melt, which can reduce ice damming on steeper metal roofs. But meltwater that runs down a cold metal panel can still refreeze at the drip edge or in the gutter. Metl-Span’s bulletin notes the dam can keep growing as long as temperatures stay below freezing and water keeps coming, and that water can get in at the wall-to-roof intersection or through seams if the seam sealant or seaming is deficient.
Ice dams on shingles
Shingles shed water by gravity; they are not a waterproof sheet. When an ice dam holds water at the eave, it can back up under the shingle courses and leak into walls and ceilings. Research summarized by Pacific Northwest National Laboratory notes ice dams can form with as little as 2 inches of snow.
That’s why Minnesota requires an ice barrier on shingle roofs. The City of Minneapolis re-roofing handout calls for it from the eave to at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall line. Metal roof specifications commonly include an ice-barrier membrane as well; the national Cost vs Value project for a standing-seam roof, for example, specifies one at the roof perimeter. Follow the panel manufacturer’s underlayment requirements and local code.
The fix is in the attic
For either roof, the long-term cure is stopping heat from reaching the roof deck. The Minnesota Department of Commerce recommends sealing attic air leaks first and then insulating to at least R-50 where space allows. A new roof is the perfect time to address this, since the deck and eaves are exposed. If ice dams have been a problem in your house, budget for air sealing and insulation no matter which roofing you choose.
Hail Resistance and Insurance
Hail season in Minnesota starts in late May in the southern part of the state and early June in the north. Both roofing types can be built to resist hail, but they fail in different ways.
How impact ratings work
The most common impact standard is UL 2218. To earn its top Class 4 rating, a product must survive a 2-inch steel ball dropped from 20 feet onto multiple spots without cracking through. Many metal panels and a growing number of asphalt shingles carry Class 4 ratings. Ratings apply to the specific product and how it’s tested, so check the label or the manufacturer’s literature rather than assuming all “metal” or all “architectural” products are equal.
Hail on metal roofs
Metal rarely cracks or punctures in typical hail, but it can dent. Ask the manufacturer for the panel’s impact rating and how its gauge, profile and finish are expected to hold up to hail. The big question is insurance: some policies include a cosmetic damage exclusion that doesn’t pay for dents that leave the roof still able to keep water out. A Minnesota federal court case over hail-dented metal roofs on school buildings turned on exactly that kind of wording. Before choosing metal, ask your agent how your policy treats cosmetic hail damage to metal roofing.
Hail on shingles
According to the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS), hail damage on shingles shows up as random impact marks, soft “bruises” and cracks, often with granules knocked loose. Damage can be hard to see from the ground and may take months to show up as leaks. Impact-rated shingles, usually made with rubberized (SBS-modified) asphalt, resist that damage much better than standard shingles.
Read the fine print either way. Some manufacturers of impact-rated shingles state plainly that the shingles are not warranted against hail damage, even though they may qualify for insurance discounts. Minnesota’s Strengthen Minnesota Homes program uses the IBHS FORTIFIED roof standard, and state law requires insurers to offer a premium discount for FORTIFIED roofs, so ask your insurer what they offer for either material.
If you think a storm has already damaged your roof, see our guide to hail damage roof repair before filing anything.
Wind Ratings Compared
Strong straight-line winds and severe thunderstorms are part of Minnesota summers, so wind resistance matters on both roof types.
Shingle wind ratings
Asphalt shingles are wind-tested under ASTM D3161. Class D shingles are tested at 90 mph and Class F at 110 mph, according to NRCA’s Professional Roofing magazine. Real-world performance depends heavily on installation: correct nail placement, starter strips at the eaves and rakes, and sealant strips that actually bond. Shingles installed in cold weather may not seal until warm weather arrives, which leaves them more vulnerable to wind in the meantime.
Metal roof wind ratings
Metal roof panels are tested as assemblies. Common tests include UL 580, which assigns uplift classes such as UL 30, UL 60 and UL 90; UL 1897, which pushes the assembly until it fails; and ASTM E1592, a structural test that finds failure pressures. These results apply only to the panel, clips, fasteners, deck and spacing used in the test, so the installation must match the tested assembly to get that performance.
Standing-seam panels attach with clips hidden under the seams, while exposed-fastener panels are screwed through the face. Both can perform well when installed to the manufacturer’s instructions; the difference is mostly in maintenance, covered below.
Cold Weather and Installation Season
Minnesota winters affect how each roof is installed and how it behaves afterward.
Shingles in the cold
GAF notes that asphalt shingles lose flexibility below about 40°F and that their self-seal strips need warmth to activate. The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA) says sealing time in cold weather depends on roof slope, orientation and sun, and recommends hand-sealing in some conditions. Shingle roofs can be installed in winter, but crews have to take extra care with storage, handling and sealing.
Metal in the cold
Metal doesn’t depend on sealant strips, so cold weather affects it less during installation. What metal does do is expand and contract with temperature swings. Standing-seam systems use clips designed to let panels move, while exposed-fastener panels rely on screws through the panel, where repeated movement can work fasteners loose over time. Panel length, fastening pattern and the manufacturer’s instructions all matter here.
Either way, winter roofing is work for a professional crew with proper fall protection. Snow and frost on a roof deck make it dangerous, and no homeowner should be up there in winter.
Lifespan, Maintenance and Repairs
Lifespan is metal’s biggest selling point. InterNACHI’s life expectancy chart estimates 40 to 80 years for metal roofing, compared with about 20 years for 3-tab shingles and about 30 years for architectural shingles. Those are rough guides, and the organization stresses they are not warranties. Ventilation, attic moisture, hail history and installation quality all shift the real number.
Maintaining a shingle roof
- Look for missing, cracked or curling shingles after windstorms and hail, ideally with binoculars from the ground.
- Watch for heavy granule buildup in gutters, which can signal aging or hail damage.
- Keep gutters clear and check flashing around chimneys, vents and skylights.
Maintaining a metal roof
- On exposed-fastener roofs, have a pro periodically check screws and their rubber washers, which can loosen or deteriorate with age and sun.
- Check sealants and flashing at penetrations, ridges and walls.
- Keep an eye on snow guards, gutters and anything below the eave after heavy winters.
- Touch up deep scratches as the panel manufacturer recommends; see our guide on whether you can paint metal roofing for more on refinishing.
Repairs
Shingles are simple to repair: a roofer can replace a few damaged shingles in a short visit, and matching is usually easy if the product is still made. Metal repairs are more specialized. Damaged panels often have to be replaced full-length, and the profile and color need to match. That’s not a reason to avoid metal, but it is a reason to keep leftover panels and trim from the original job.
Is a Metal Roof Louder in Rain or Hail?
This is one of the most common worries, and it mostly comes from barns and sheds where metal is fastened over open framing. On a house, metal roofing is installed over solid sheathing with underlayment, and the attic insulation sits between the roof and your living space. The Metal Construction Association says a metal roof built that way is no noisier than any other type of roof in a hailstorm.
If you have a vaulted ceiling or a finished attic with little space between roof and room, ask the installer about underlayment and insulation details that help deaden sound.
Cost and Resale Value
Metal costs more upfront. In Remodeling magazine’s Cost vs Value 2025 report, the national average for replacing a roughly 3,000-square-foot roof (tear-off included) was about $31,900 for asphalt shingles and about $51,900 for standing-seam metal. The same report estimated asphalt shingle replacement recouped about 68% of its cost at resale, compared with about 50% for metal.
Those are national ballpark figures for a defined sample project, not Minneapolis quotes. Roof size, pitch, tear-off layers, deck repairs, ventilation, panel type and snow guards all change the price, and a written estimate is the only way to know your number. Our roof replacement cost page walks through what drives price in the Twin Cities.
The longer view matters too. If metal lasts through what would have been one or two shingle replacements, the gap narrows over decades. If you plan to sell in a few years, shingles usually make more financial sense.
Which Roof Fits Your Minneapolis Home?
There’s no universal winner. These rules of thumb cover most situations:
Metal tends to make sense if:
- You plan to stay in the house for decades and want to avoid another reroof.
- The roof is fairly simple and steep enough to shed snow, and you can design safe landing zones or full snow-guard coverage.
- You want a roof that clears itself of snow load faster after big storms.
- You’ve confirmed how your insurance treats cosmetic hail dents.
Shingles tend to make sense if:
- Upfront budget matters most, or you may sell within several years.
- The roof has lots of valleys, dormers or entrances under the eaves where sliding snow would be a problem.
- You want easy, inexpensive spot repairs after storms.
- You’d consider impact-rated shingles for hail protection at a lower cost than metal.
Whatever you choose, the quality of the roof installation, plus attic air sealing, insulation and ventilation, will do more for winter performance than the roofing material alone. If you’re leaning toward metal, our metal roofing page covers panel types and options, and our overview of how metal roofing is installed explains what goes on under the panels.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do metal roofs get ice dams?
Yes. Metal sheds snow more easily, which can reduce ice damming, but meltwater can still refreeze at the eave or in the gutter. Air sealing and insulating the attic is the real fix for either roof type.
Do I need snow guards on a metal roof in Minnesota?
Usually, if snow could slide onto doors, walkways, driveways, decks, lower roofs or equipment. Guards should cover the full eave line and be laid out using the manufacturer’s engineering for your snow load and roof slope.
Is a metal roof louder than shingles?
Not much when it’s installed over solid sheathing with underlayment and an insulated attic. The loud metal roofs people remember are usually on barns or sheds with open framing.
How long does a metal roof last compared to shingles?
InterNACHI estimates 40 to 80 years for metal, about 20 years for 3-tab shingles and about 30 years for architectural shingles. Actual life depends on installation, ventilation and storm exposure.
Does hail damage metal roofs?
Hail can dent metal, though it rarely punctures it. Some insurance policies exclude cosmetic dents that don’t cause leaks, so ask your agent how your policy handles metal roofing.
Will a metal roof lower my home insurance premium?
It may. Some insurers offer discounts for impact-rated roofs, including metal and Class 4 shingles, and Minnesota requires insurers to offer a discount for FORTIFIED roofs. Ask your insurer before you choose.
Metal and shingles can both handle a Minnesota winter well when the roof is designed for snow and the attic below it is tight and well insulated. Weigh how long you’ll stay, how snow will leave your roof, and how your insurance treats hail before deciding.
Want to compare both options on your own house? Call Minneapolis Roofing Company at (888) 657-0348 for a free estimate.

