The best roofing material for Minnesota, for most homes, is either an impact-rated architectural asphalt shingle or a standing seam metal roof. Both stand up to deep cold, heavy snow and hail when they are installed with a code-required ice barrier and a well-sealed, well-insulated attic. Synthetic slate, natural slate and cedar can work beautifully too, but they cost more and have trade-offs.
No material stops ice dams on its own, and hail is a bigger threat to most Twin Cities roofs than cold. Below we compare the main options for Minnesota winters, including how each one handles snow, hail and ice dams, what the code requires, and what we can responsibly say about cost.
In this article
- The best roofing material for Minnesota: quick answer
- What a Minnesota roof has to handle
- Minnesota roofing materials compared
- Asphalt shingles: architectural and impact-rated
- Metal roofing
- Synthetic slate and shake
- Natural slate
- Cedar shakes and shingles
- Flat and low-slope membranes
- Ice dams: what matters more than the material
- Cost: what we can say with confidence
- How to choose for your home
- Frequently Asked Questions
The best roofing material for Minnesota: quick answer
- Best overall value: architectural asphalt shingles, ideally Class 4 impact-rated with a strong independent hail rating.
- Best long-term pick for pitched roofs: standing seam metal, if the budget allows and you plan to stay in the home.
- Best for a slate or shake look with less weight: synthetic (composite) slate or shake.
- Best for historic homes and very long service life: natural slate, installed by a slate specialist.
- Best for flat and low-slope roofs: EPDM, TPO or SBS modified bitumen, chosen around drainage and details.
The rest of this guide explains why, and when the “best” choice changes for a particular house.
What a Minnesota roof has to handle
Minnesota roofs face a tough combination of conditions:
- Snow load: Minnesota’s building rules set ground snow loads of 50 pounds per square foot in most counties, including the Twin Cities, and 60 pounds per square foot in listed northern counties. Roof framing has to carry that weight, which matters for heavy materials such as slate.
- Ice dams: the University of Minnesota Extension explains that ice dams form when snow sits on a roof whose upper part is above 32°F while the eaves are below freezing, usually because heat leaks out of the house into the attic.
- Hail: hail season in Minnesota typically starts in late May in the south and early June in the north, according to state climatologist Mark Seeley. Twin Cities storms have produced hail up to golf-ball size.
- Freeze-thaw cycles: repeated freezing and thawing stresses materials, flashing and sealants, and any water that gets into cracks expands when it freezes.
- Short installation seasons: asphalt shingles need warmth and sun to seal, so cold-weather installs need extra steps such as hand-sealing.
The code also builds in winter protection. Minnesota requires an ice barrier on homes, running from the eave edge to at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall line, whatever material goes on top.
Minnesota roofing materials compared
This table summarizes how each material handles Minnesota conditions. Lifespan figures are home inspector estimates from InterNACHI and assume good installation and regular maintenance.
| Material | Estimated life | Cold and snow | Hail | Minimum slope (IRC) | Relative cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Architectural asphalt shingles | About 30 years | Good with ice barrier; needs warmth to seal | Standard shingles vulnerable; Class 4 options available | 2:12 (double underlayment below 4:12) | Lowest of the pitched options |
| Metal (standing seam, panels, shingles) | 40 to 80 years | Sheds snow well; needs snow guards in places | Class 4 panels available; dents may be cosmetic | 1/4:12 standing seam; 3:12 for lapped panels without sealant | Higher |
| Synthetic slate or shake | 10 to 35 years (InterNACHI); varies widely by product | Good; check product cold-weather limits | Many products Class 4 | Per manufacturer; often 3:12 or more | Higher |
| Natural slate | 60 to 150 years | Excellent frost resistance when high quality | Can crack under large hail | 4:12 | Highest |
| Cedar shakes and shingles | About 25 years | Needs good drying and ventilation | Can split | 3:12 | Higher |
| Flat membranes (EPDM, TPO, mod bit) | EPDM 15 to 25, TPO 7 to 20, mod bit about 20 | Depends on drainage and detailing | Varies by membrane and cover board | 1/4:12 | Varies |
Asphalt shingles: architectural and impact-rated
Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing product in the US, and they are the default choice on most Minnesota homes. Architectural (laminated) shingles are thicker than old three-tab shingles and are estimated to last about 30 years, compared with about 20 for three-tab, according to InterNACHI.
How asphalt handles Minnesota winters
Asphalt shingles handle cold fine once installed. Their weak points in winter are installation and ice dams. The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association notes that shingles rely on sun and warmth to activate their seal strips, so cold-weather installs may need hand-sealing and should wait until the deck is free of ice and frost.
The code also adds protection for low slopes. Asphalt shingles need a minimum slope of 2:12, and slopes between 2:12 and 4:12 require two layers of underlayment.
Why impact rating matters here
Hail is the main reason Minnesota homeowners replace asphalt roofs. Impact-resistant shingles are tested under UL 2218, where Class 4 means the shingle survives a 2-inch steel ball dropped from 20 feet onto the same spots without cracking.
Class 4 is a starting point, not the whole story. The Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS) tests impact-resistant shingles with realistic laboratory hailstones. Its November 2025 ratings covered 24 products and rated most as Good, none as Excellent, and some as Marginal or Poor. IBHS reports that all shingles rated Good or Excellent at 2-inch hail were polymer-modified asphalt, and that they cost about 9 percent more per square on average in the markets it checked.
Minnesota also encourages stronger roofs. State law requires insurers to provide a premium discount for homes that meet the IBHS FORTIFIED standard, including the hail supplement, and the state’s Strengthen Minnesota Homes program has offered grants toward FORTIFIED roofs. Ask your insurer what discount it offers before choosing a shingle.
Bottom line on asphalt
For most Twin Cities homes, a polymer-modified, Class 4 architectural shingle with a strong IBHS rating offers the best balance of cost, hail performance and ease of repair. For more on what goes into a new shingle roof, see our roof installation page.
Metal roofing
Metal is the most popular upgrade from asphalt in cold climates, and for good reason. InterNACHI estimates a metal roof lasts 40 to 80 years, and a Metal Construction Association study of unpainted aluminum-zinc coated standing seam roofs found no significant red rust at sites up to 35 years old and projected service lives of more than 60 years with regular inspection.
Snow and cold
Metal’s smooth surface helps snow slide off, which can reduce how long snow sits on the roof. That benefit has a downside: large slabs of snow and ice can slide off suddenly. Snow guards are common over entries, walkways, decks, driveways and lower roofs.
Metal also expands and contracts with temperature. One metal manufacturer notes that a 30-foot steel panel moves about 1/4 inch over a 100°F temperature swing, and aluminum moves almost twice as much. Quality systems use floating clips so panels can move without stressing fasteners, which matters in Minnesota’s big seasonal swings.
Slope and types
Standing seam metal panels are allowed on slopes as low as 1/4:12 under the model residential code, while lapped panels without sealant need 3:12 and metal shingles need 3:12. That makes standing seam useful on low-pitch sections that are tricky for shingles.
Hail
Some metal panels carry a UL 2218 Class 4 rating, meaning the panel does not crack or rupture under the test impacts. Dents are a separate issue: a Class 4 metal roof can still dent cosmetically, and some insurance policies limit coverage for cosmetic damage. Check your policy before choosing a metal profile and gauge.
Bottom line on metal
Metal is a strong choice for Minnesota homeowners planning to stay long-term, for low-slope sections, and for homes where snow shedding is a benefit rather than a hazard. Learn more on our metal roofing page.
Synthetic slate and shake
Synthetic, or composite, roofing is made from polymers, rubber or recycled materials molded to look like slate or cedar shake. It is much lighter than natural slate, and many products carry Class 4 impact and Class A fire ratings.
Points to check for Minnesota:
- Cold-weather behavior: at least one composite tile maker notes that some plastic shingles can become brittle in freezing climates. Ask for cold-climate performance data and installation temperature limits.
- Installation rules: one major synthetic slate maker’s guide does not allow its product below 3:12, requires full self-adhered membrane coverage between 3:12 and 4:12, and calls for self-adhered membrane at the eaves extending 2 feet past the exterior wall where the average January temperature is 25°F or less.
- Track record: lifespan estimates for synthetic slate vary widely. InterNACHI lists 10 to 35 years, while manufacturers often offer much longer limited warranties. Look at warranty terms and how long the specific product has been on the market.
Synthetic slate and shake make sense when you want a premium look, better hail performance and no structural upgrades, and you are willing to pay more than for asphalt.
Natural slate
Natural slate is the longest-lived common roofing material. InterNACHI estimates 60 to 150 years, and the National Park Service’s preservation guidance gives general life expectancies ranging from more than 60 years for some soft slates to about 125 years for Vermont and New York slates and 175 years or more for Virginia’s Buckingham slate.
How slate handles cold
The National Park Service explains that low porosity and low absorption help slate resist frost damage, and that slate weathering is driven mainly by chemical impurities rather than cold alone. In other words, a high-quality slate can do very well in Minnesota.
Trade-offs
- Weight: slate is far heavier than asphalt. Combined with Minnesota’s snow loads, the roof structure often needs an engineer’s review.
- Slope: the code requires at least 4:12.
- Details: slate needs copper or stainless steel nails and long-lasting metal flashing, since ordinary steel nails can rust out before the slate wears out.
- Hail and foot traffic: slate can crack from large hail or from being walked on. The National Park Service advises against walking on slate roofs.
- Specialists: slate work requires experienced installers, which limits availability and raises cost.
Slate is best for historic homes that already have it, or for owners building for the very long term.
Cedar shakes and shingles
Cedar gives a warm, natural look that suits many older Minnesota homes and cabins. InterNACHI estimates about 25 years for wood roofs, though life varies with climate, maintenance and how well the roof dries out.
Cold-climate considerations:
- Moisture and drying: wood needs to dry between wet periods. Shade, debris, moss and poor ventilation shorten its life.
- Code details: wood shingles and shakes need at least a 3:12 slope. Where the average January temperature is 25°F or less, the code requires solid sheathing under the part of the roof that needs an ice barrier, and shakes are interlaid with felt strips.
- Fire: untreated wood is combustible. Fire-retardant-treated products exist, and some areas restrict wood roofs.
- Hail: wood can split under hail, especially as it ages.
Cedar is a look-driven choice. If you want the appearance with less maintenance, synthetic shake is worth comparing.
Flat and low-slope membranes
Many Minneapolis homes have flat or low-slope sections, such as porches, additions, garages and duplex roofs. Shingles are not the answer below 2:12. Built-up, modified bitumen and single-ply membranes are designed for slopes of 1/4:12 and up.
EPDM
EPDM is a synthetic rubber membrane with an estimated life of 15 to 25 years, per InterNACHI. It stays flexible in cold weather. Like any membrane, its weak points are seams, edges and penetrations.
TPO and PVC
TPO and PVC are thermoplastic single-ply membranes with heat-welded seams. InterNACHI estimates 7 to 20 years for TPO. Welded seams are a strength, but installation quality varies.
Modified bitumen
Modified bitumen is asphalt modified with polymers and usually installed in two or more layers. For Minnesota, the type matters: technical course material from a major membrane maker notes that SBS-modified bitumen stays flexible below -20°F, while APP-modified material becomes brittle below about 23°F. Roofing manuals also note that APP is difficult to install in cold weather. SBS is generally the better fit for cold climates.
What matters most on flat roofs
On a Minnesota flat roof, drainage and details matter more than the membrane brand. Standing water freezes and thaws, snow piles up, and ice can block drains and scuppers. Make sure the roof has positive slope to drains, enough insulation to limit melting, and clean, well-flashed edges and penetrations. Our flat roofing page covers the options in more detail.
Ice dams: what matters more than the material
It is tempting to think a new material will solve ice dams. It will not. The University of Minnesota Extension identifies heat loss from the house, mainly through air leaks into the attic, as the main cause. The Minnesota Department of Commerce recommends sealing attic air leaks and insulating the attic to at least R-50 where space allows.
What the roof can do is limit damage when ice dams form:
- Ice barrier: the code-required self-adhering membrane at the eaves, extending at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall line. Many contractors extend it farther on low slopes, in valleys and around penetrations.
- Ventilation: proper intake and exhaust ventilation helps keep the roof deck cold and dry.
- Snow-shedding surfaces: metal may clear snow faster, but it still needs good attic air sealing and insulation.
A reroof is the best time to fix attic air sealing, insulation and ventilation, because the deck is exposed and the crew is already there.
Cost: what we can say with confidence
Roofing prices vary widely by home size, roof complexity, tear-off layers, material grade, access and season, so we only share figures from a credible published source. Remodeling magazine’s 2025 Cost vs. Value report, a national survey, puts the average job cost of an asphalt shingle roof replacement at $31,871 and a metal roof replacement at $51,865 for its model projects.
Treat those as national ballpark figures, not a quote. Other cost points we can support:
- IBHS found that impact-resistant shingles rated Good or Excellent cost about 9 percent more per square on average than standard shingles in the markets it surveyed.
- Natural slate, synthetic slate and cedar generally cost more than asphalt, and slate may need structural upgrades.
- Insurance discounts for FORTIFIED roofs and impact-rated shingles can offset part of the cost over time.
The only way to know what your roof will cost is a written estimate based on your home. Our roof replacement cost guide explains the main factors that move the price.
How to choose for your home
Use these questions to narrow the choice:
- What is the roof pitch? Below 2:12 you need a membrane or standing seam metal. Between 2:12 and 4:12, asphalt needs double underlayment and slate is not allowed.
- How long will you stay? If you plan to stay for decades, metal or slate can make sense. If you may sell in a few years, a quality asphalt roof is usually the better value.
- How worried are you about hail? If you have had hail claims before, put impact performance near the top of the list and check IBHS ratings.
- Can the structure carry it? Slate and some tile systems are heavy; snow loads add more.
- What does the house call for? Historic homes and neighborhoods may suit slate or cedar, or a synthetic that mimics them.
- What will your insurer reward? Ask about discounts for impact-rated or FORTIFIED roofs before you buy.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best roofing material for Minnesota winters?
For most Minnesota homes, impact-rated architectural asphalt shingles or a standing seam metal roof are the best fit. Both handle cold and snow well when installed with a proper ice barrier, and the right choice depends on budget, roof shape and how long you plan to stay.
Is a metal roof good in Minnesota?
Yes. Metal sheds snow well, resists rot and can last for decades, and standing seam systems are rated for very low slopes. Plan for snow guards where sliding snow could hit walkways, decks or lower roofs, and know that hail can dent some panels.
Are impact-resistant shingles worth it in Minnesota?
Often, yes, because Minnesota gets regular hail. Look for shingles rated Class 4 under UL 2218 and, ideally, rated Good or Excellent in IBHS testing, and ask your insurer whether it offers a discount.
Do metal roofs prevent ice dams?
Not by themselves. Ice dams are caused by heat escaping into the attic and melting snow on the upper roof. Metal can shed snow faster, but air sealing, insulation and an ice barrier at the eaves are still needed.
Is slate a good roof for cold climates?
High-quality slate can last a very long time in cold climates and resists frost because of its low absorption. It is heavy and expensive, needs a strong roof structure and specialist installers, and should not be walked on.
What roofing material lasts the longest in Minnesota?
Natural slate and metal have the longest expected lifespans, with home inspector estimates of 60 to 150 years for slate and 40 to 80 years for metal. Actual life depends on installation quality, ventilation and maintenance.
What is the best material for a flat roof in Minnesota?
EPDM, TPO and SBS modified bitumen are all common on low-slope roofs here. SBS modified bitumen and EPDM stay flexible in deep cold, while TPO and PVC are heat-welded single-ply options; the details and drainage matter more than the label.
Choosing the best roofing material for a Minnesota home comes down to pitch, budget, hail exposure and how long you plan to stay, with a code-compliant ice barrier and a well-sealed attic under whatever you pick.
Want help comparing materials for your roof? Call Minneapolis Roofing Company at (888) 657-0348 for a free estimate.

